Click here to support the Daily Grail for as little as $US1 per month on Patreon

Earth <---- Food Here!

Alan Boyle posted an interesting article at Cosmic Log this week on whether we should be trying to contact ET (though you’d already know that, because you’ve got it bookmarked – right?!). He quotes David Brin, who is wary of what he calls METI (Messages to Extraterrestrial Intelligences – aka ‘Active SETI‘), warning of the possible consequences of “shouting into an unknown jungle that we do not understand”. Brin authored a Lifeboat Foundation report a few years ago titled “Shouting at the Cosmos: …Or How SETI has Taken a Worrisome Turn Into Dangerous Territory”. He believes there should be regulation, on behalf of the people of the Earth, as to what is allowed to be broadcast ‘out there’.

As I’ve noted before, I do find it quite funny how ufologists are routinely dismissed because there’s apparently no way that ET could ever travel the vast distances to the Earth, and yet we have this serious debate taking place about the dangers of inviting extraterrestrials to…travel to Earth!

Anyhow, I’ve created a new poll which asks you for your opinion. Share your answer to the question, and if you want to expand on it, please feel free to comment on the poll. Older polls are archived here, including the most recent one in which the majority of respondents believed conspiracy was involved in the collapse of WTC 7.

Editor
  1. Hellllooo!
    I think it might be more prudent to be ‘listening’ for contacts from ET rather than randomly broadcasting our existence – at least until we have some idea of to whom, or what, we might be sending messages.

    However, that being said, I think we have probably already been found! Thus, it would appear, that in general ET doesn’t want to talk to us (or maybe only to those in positions of authority). Viewed from an outside perspective, we no doubt look like the savages we really are.

    Regards, Kathrinn

    1. interesting
      I think they have found us, just because some radio frequencies from our system are brighter than just the sun’s output. So this has changed since about 1940 or so, and anyone who si wtching our star would notice that. Not that they have deciphered anything.

      But we are just not very interesting. Not interesting enough to travel across interstellar distances. That would be expensive. And you know how developed societies like to spend money on entertainment, rather than exploration.

      —-
      The large print giveth,
      The small print taketh away.

      1. Yes but
        Maybe they would like to come here, just for the entertainment value. Maybe to shoot some “Reality TV shows” or something? 😉

        But I agree, all those worries might be valid, but are already futile. We’ve been shouting out our existence in several different ways from quite some time now. We sent messages on space probes that are about to enter interstellar space. We’ve even let an invitation plaque on the surface of our Moon.

        Maybe what worries some people is the “anarchy” present in all these discussions. Who speaks for Earth? Who has the right to do so? We haven’t been able to understand each other, to begin to relate each other not as “Americans” or “British” but as “Earthlings”, and now we want to begin a meaningful discussion with ET. Thoe previous examples I mentioned were conducted by a government authority, but the “civilian” efforts are the ones being criticized.

        Maybe it’s a question of loosing power? If I can talk to ET without the need of the government, why do I need governments in the first place? I think that’s part of the fear and suspicion the Contactist movements of the 50s and 60s generated on some government offices (aside from the obvious conjecture those groups might be “brainwashed” by foreign enemies, of course).

        Sometimes I feel this is all hilarious, akin to a goldfish stuck in an aquarium tank worrying about the beings that might be out there and why they haven’t contacted it.

        —–
        It’s not the depth of the rabbit hole that bugs me…
        It’s all the rabbit SH*T you stumble over on your way down!!!

        Red Pill Junkie

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Mobile menu - fractal