Ronson on Sylvia Browne

I missed this last weekend, but it's worth a mention. Journalist Jon Ronson, well-known for investigating the strange topics we like to cover, did quite a long piece on superstar psychic Sylvia Browne, which was published in the Guardian. Ronson managed to get a one-on-one with the elusive Browne by joining a cruise holiday on which she was featured.

His conclusions were not positive, with only one 'hit' of note by Browne mentioned, but plenty of doubts sown about her authenticity. Based on my own reading, I'd have to agree with Ronson and wonder why Browne has the following she does - and not just because of the now infamous Shawn Hornbeck error. I have heard of many mediums who seem to be more deserving of a high profile than Sylvia Browne. More importantly, skeptics tout Browne as an example of the fraudulent nature of mediumship - and as a figurehead (whether desired or not), she leaves a lot to be desired.

On the flipside, Jon Ronson's previous work - such as The Men Who Stare At Goats (Amazon US and UK), have exhibited a humorous cynicism, rather than objective reporting (though he's not a harsh skeptic in any sense). It's certainly a topic that lends itself to that approach for public reading, with its core theme of the oxymoron of military intelligence - and Ronson's writing talent makes it a fun and fascinating read - but at the same time, we should perhaps be wary of making these topics too easily dismissed in polite conversation. But then, with people like Sylvia Browne dominating the public definition of 'psychic', a little cynicism is not only desired, but required...

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
RonB's picture
Member since:
19 August 2004
Last activity:
4 years 6 weeks

I just wanted to say that it isn't a question if Sylvia Browne is truly psychic or not (erm, I vote NOT), it's a question of how repugnant she is (VERY).

RonB
Observer of Everything, Seer of Little

Marissa's picture
Member since:
7 February 2005
Last activity:
5 years 13 weeks

I can add a little to this string.

I have a good friend, who is quite gifted with second sight or whatever you want to call it.

She went to see Sylvia and found her to be rude to her staff and insulting to her audience. My friend also saw two dark spirits come out to the stage with her.

nuff said...on that cheerful note eh? lol

kamarling's picture
Member since:
26 June 2005
Last activity:
4 days 9 hours

"exhibited a humorous cynicism, rather than objective reporting..."

I'm afraid that this is one of the dominant traits of the entertainment and news media these days. In the UK, it seems to be part of the comedian's stock-in-trade and TV and Radio News reporters seem to think that a snigger and a sneer is obligatory when reporting anything of a paranormal nature.

Last week, the otherwise brilliant Stephen Fry on his otherwise excellent and very humorous BBC show, QI, commented on the debunking career of Harry Houdini, comparing his heroic efforts to those of James Randi and Darren Brown in exposing spiritualists and mediums. "People used to believe in these things", he enlightened us all before reminding us that, of course, it was all done by magic (i.e. conjuring tricks).

David.

http://www.davidsmuse.co.uk