Daily Grail Featured Blogs

Gary Lachman's picture
Gary Lachman
Revolutionaries of the Soul (Quest 2014) is a collection of my essays and articles over the...
Greg's picture
Greg
Science needs to get over itself. And by 'science', I mean those people who see science as some...
Gary Lachman's picture
Gary Lachman
Here is an excerpt from my new book, Aleister Crowley: Magick, Rock and Roll, and The...
Gary Lachman's picture
Gary Lachman
 The Forest is Everywhere“It is essential to know that every man is immortal and that...
Julie Beischel's picture
Julie Beischel
On Friday, March 21, 2014, I'll be giving the keynote address at the Exploring the...

Story Spotlight

Martin Gardner

Today would have been the 100th birthday of the late polymath and influential skeptic Martin Gardner. Gardner – who passed away aged 95 in May 2010 – published more than seventy books on such diverse topics as mathematics, science, philosophy, literature and skepticism. For a quarter of a century he was also the writer of the ‘Mathematical Games’ column in Scientific American, and as a consequence he has influenced many of the modern day’s top academics in the hard sciences. Douglas Hofstadter described Gardner as “one of the great intellects produced in this country in this century,” and Arthur C. Clarke once labeled him a “national treasure.”

Gardner was also one of the major voices in the skeptical movement; George Hansen describes him as “the single most powerful critic of the paranormal in the second half of the 20th century”. Gardner was writing ‘skeptical’ books long before the modern movement ‘began’ in earnest with the inception of CSICOP (now known as CSI) in the 1970s – his seminal deconstruction of pseudoscience, In the Name of Science (later renamed Fads and Fallacies in the Name of Science), had been published two decades previous in 1952. Like Randi, he could be a rather nasty skeptic too, sometimes embracing debunking over debate (he once commented that in certain circumstances, "One horse laugh is worth ten thousand syllogisms").

The occasion of Gardner's 100th birthday has led to a number of tributes on major news sites this week, from the BBC to the New York Times. And rightly so, there is no doubting that he inspired a number of today's leading academics. But I also thought it worth pointing out his fallibility, by relinking to my article "How Martin Gardner Bamboozled the Skeptics", which I think (hope!) does a good job in deconstructing the truly awful 'skeptical' essay he wrote about the medium Leonora Piper. Rather than denigrating Gardner's memory, I would hope that a man who esteemed skeptical thinking as much as Gardner would appreciate my critique of this particular work of his. It's a long piece, so here's the summary:

Unscientific skepticism of the type exhibited by Gardner and Cattel is a corrosive one which, rather than defending science, instead shields it from possible new discoveries and viewpoints through irrational over-protectiveness. It also brings skepticism as a whole into disrepute when such cheap tactics are employed. In his article “How Mrs. Piper Bamboozled William James”, Martin Gardner ignores the original scientific work done, misrepresents the competency of the investigators, and misleads the reader both through incorrect statements and loaded language. This is hardly the type of writing we would expect from “one of the great intellects produced in this country in this century.”

Sadly for Martin Gardner, perhaps the most succinct summary of his essay can be found in James Hyslop’s caustic response to Hall and Tanner’s Studies in Spiritism, written nearly 100 years previous: "The calm critic can only say that the book either displays the grossest ignorance of the facts and the subject, or it is a colossal piece of constructive lying. The authors may take either horn of the dilemma they like."

Link: Skeptical of a Skeptic

Related: Vale Martin Gardner

 

Daily News Scan

(Posted by Grail-seeker on Wednesday, October 22nd)

The world hasn't run out of stories just yet.

Quote of the Day:

Stories of imagination tend to upset those without one.

Terry Pratchett

Recent posts

Type Title Authorsort icon Replies Last Post
Story Radio 08-04-2005 admin 8 Apr 2005 - 2:27am
Story Radio 08-06-2005 admin 8 Apr 2005 - 2:22am
Story Scientific Literature on UFOs admin 24 May 2010 - 2:14pm
BC_gizathetruth admin 5 May 2004 - 12:04pm
Story Anonymous Commenting Update admin 6 18 Jan 2011 - 9:15am
BC_gizathetruth_0 admin 5 May 2004 - 12:04pm
Story Paranthropology 5:1 admin 24 Jan 2014 - 1:14pm
BC_Underworld admin 5 May 2004 - 12:04pm
Story Magical Archetypes admin 7 Nov 2005 - 4:46am
Page Daily Grail Frontpage admin 6 Sep 2009 - 9:17am

Recent Comments

Charles Pope's picture
Charles Pope
Charles Pope's picture
Charles Pope
red pill junkie's picture
red pill junkie
red pill junkie's picture
red pill junkie